Education: The Perfect Financial Storm

Andrew spends his days (and I suspect many nights) at Dartmouth where, as he has reminded us before, he is on the front lines of some of the biggest education battles being waged these days.  And Pete has a very personal commitment to education that he has shared with us.

But every once in a while I get to play in this area as well.  Several years ago, for example, I briefly was a member of a special committee at a major university in the Washington, D..C. area that was trying to figure out how to reconfigure its student aid program (I left when I was told that we were not allowed to talk about how to lower spending, only loans vs. grants).

About a week ago, i participated in a forum hosted by the Committee for Education Funding in Washington so I had a chance to weigh in on what the education community -- that's everything from pre-school through graduate school -- may be facing as far as finances and the federal budget are concerned.

I listed the following:

1.  Home equity loans not being available to pay tuition at private K-12 schools and colleges and universities.

2.  Pressure on the federal government to hold the line on domestic appropriations. Education is the largest percentage of that part of the budget.

3.  Lower property taxes because of the housing problem.  That means that there will be less money in the traditional way many state and local governments fund education.

4.  Consumers with less disposable income means that fewer people will play the lottery, which in theory provides money for education in many states.

5.  The credit market problems mean that colleges and universities will have trouble borrowing.  Even Harvard, with its $35 billion endowment, recently had problems in this area.

6.  A suddenly increased demand for K-12 public schools.  Is there any doubt that parents who feel the need to cut back on expenses may decide that the private school their daughter or son either were thinking about or have been attending is suddenly a bit too expensive and that public schools are a more attractive alternative than they used to be?

7.  A suddenly increased demand for state colleges and universities.  The fall in the stock markets almost certainly means that the amount that some parents had put aside to pay for college is no longer enough to pay the tuition at a private school. Having a child live at home and commute to a school where he or she qualifies for in-state tuition may well be a much more common alternative than it was just a few years ago.  Other parents may have the money to pay for private tuition and fees but decide that it's needed for other purposes.

8.  The continuing problems with the availability of student loans.

9.  The fact that the default rates on student loans are likely to increase as the economy worsens.  This will increase the on-budget costs of these loans and, therefore, make them more expensive at the same time there will be pressure on federal domestic spending (see #2 above).

10.  Because of the economy and falling stock markets, the likely reduction in charitable contributions by alumni.

All of this seems to argue that education will be a bigger issue in Washington next year than anyone is currently admitting.

 

 

Harvard alums

Harvard alums: your school has a friggin' $35 billion endowment. The students (many from wealthy legacy families) are eating gourmet food off fine china while the admin sits on a pile of cash that does nobody any good.

My advice: Make your check to a mid tier college that spends the money on the student's educations, practices need-blind admissions, and holds the line on tuition (no fine dining, and the dorms are spartan, but the point is getting an education).

I recommend schools like Beloit College. Beloit is an academically rigorous, unpretentious institution that ranks in the top 20 liberal arts colleges in sending students to graduate schools. An extremely high number of their science grads go on to receive PhDs in their fields (something like 90%). The focus is on quality teaching at Beloit.

With a very un-Harvard endowment of less than $100 million -- even though they have extremely high alum participation in the annual fund drive -- Beloit just announced a budget shortfall and a 10% staff cut.

These middle tier colleges produce a fine product -- alums who are leaders in research, international business, and education.

Give to an institution that has demonstrated need and gets the job done without the frills. The Ivies will be just fine, and should stop their panhandling as Samwick says. $35 billion in the bank should get them through a rough patch.

It's the middle tier schools that will suffer the most during this economic downturn. My money is going to Beloit, because I know that students will benefit immediately from my giving. I suggest that wealthy individuals looking to donate to quality institutions where they get the most "bang for the buck" -- investigate the value at colleges like Beloit.

My .02. But I sent a lot more to Beloit. Excellent school.

Dartmouth follows Beloit

10% budget cut needed, just announced today:

http://www.dartmouth.edu/~presoff/1113.html

Harvard follows Beloit too

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options