StanCollender'sCapitalGainsandGames Washington, Wall Street and Everything in Between

State Budget Challenges Catch Washington's Attention

08 Feb 2011
Posted by Pete Davis
A year ago, most states hoped the economy would be strong enough this year that they wouldn't have to cope with deficits like those of the past two years. Unfortunately, economic recovery has been weak and they face continued revenue shortfalls and the cessation of stimulus spending that sustained them through the recession. On February 3, National Governors Association Executive Director Ray Scheppach told the Senate Budget Committee that despite adopting $75 billion of spending cuts and $33 billion of tax increases over the past two years, the states will have to trim another $175 billion over the next few years. Today's Washington Post has this handy chart and detailed article showing what mostly new governors from both parties are up against and what they're proposing. Yesterday's Center for Budget and Policy Priorities analysis adds a lot more.
Last November, the market hammered municipal bonds when these fiscal challenges became apparent and when Congress chose to end the Build America Bond Program. Ever since, there has been talk of state bankruptcies and municipal defaults. Arkansas defaulted during the Depression and some states defaulted during the Civil War, but, as this Center for Budget and Policy Priorities analysis shows, these fears are exaggerated. Fed Chair Ben Bernanke downplayed default talk on January 7 before the Senate Budget Committee. This 60 Minutes interview with leading financial analyst Meredith Whitney on December 19 set off another selloff when she predicted 50 to 100 municipal defaults.
What's Washington up to now regarding the states? My recent conversations with top Hill staff reveal an aversion to any more bailouts. Last December 2, Rep. Devin Nunes (R-CA) and House Budget Chair Paul Ryan (R-WI) introduced H.R.6484 to prevent any bailouts of states and to require them to disclose pension liabilities. Today, several news outlets are reporting President Obama will propose to raise unemployment taxes on behalf of the states starting in 2014 without increasing federal unemployment tax revenues by raising the current covered wage from $7,000, where it's been since 1983, to $15,000 and by lowering the 6.2% federal tax rate commensurately. That would give the states nearly $100 billion through 2023. This is the kind of slick fiscal policy that staff stay up nights trying to think up. It has some attractive characteristics, but House Republicans won't go along with any tax increase, even if Republican governors are begging them to adopt it. That will leave the states praying the economy improves.

State finances incredibly important, picture seriously negative

Thanks for excellent post about something that seriously matters to those of us who... live in states... have children who go to public schools... care about libraries or the mentally ill, homeless or seniors. A friend of mine in State Government Affairs told me that, on average, states recover two years after the national economy does. And the reality is that the national "recovery" will take a long time, and for some states with high unemployment or high Medicaid populations it's going to be a lot longer than two years [and then there are the underfunded pension/healthcare liabilities]. This is an enormous problem because with states on something of a PAYGO basis, and Medicaid as their highest cost, education, not only K-12, but also public colleges et al, get even more underfunded, so quality or access is affected. My kid has 29 kids in her classroom now, what will it be 2014? We need America to be educationally competitive - states' fiscal realities will make improvement extremely challenging. Our library has cut back its hours - what about all the people that can't afford books or computers? Literacy is important in a democracy, meritocracy. Also, I expect defaults, with some ripple effect - that's just probability in a system that is so incredibly strained.

Recent comments


Order from Amazon


Creative Commons LicenseThe content of is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. Need permissions beyond the scope of this license? Please submit a request here.