StanCollender'sCapitalGainsandGames Washington, Wall Street and Everything in Between

Jobs Bill Just Got Bipartisan Senate Support

22 Feb 2010
Posted by Pete Davis

It's too early to get our hopes up for sustained Senate bipartisanship, but just before 6 p.m. tonight, five Republicans joined 57 Democrats to invoke cloture on Senator Harry Reid's (D-NV) amendment to the House jobs bill, H.R.2847. Newly elected Scott Brown (R-MA), Kit Bond (R-MO), Sue Collins (R-ME), Olympia Snow (R-ME), and George Voinovitch (R-OH) voted with the Democrats. Ben Nelson (D-NE) was the only Democrat to vote with the Republicans. Not voting were Frank Lautenberg (D-NJ), who is hospitalized for stomach cancer, and eight Republicans, who ducked the vote. So far, Reid's amendment would be limited to $12 b. FY10-FY12, and it's "paid for" over 10 years, but amendments could add to that, and it will grow larger in any compromise with the House's $65 b. FY10-FY19 bill.

Reid's amendment is outlined here, and its CBO cost estimate is here.
The House bill is described here, and its cost estimate is here.
I'm not a big fan of throwing money at job creation because too much is spent ineffectively or too late, but I am concerned enough about declining economic growth in the second half of this year to believe that additional stimulus is warranted. The Fed is going to stop buying mortgage backed securities at the end of next month, several million mortgage foreclosures will be finalized during the second half, commercial real estate will continue its decline, and banks remain reluctant to lend,
I am hopeful that the Senate can continue to find ways to hammer out bipartisan compromises on these issues which cry out for legislation:
  1. Jobs bill
  2. Deficit reduction for FY12 and beyond
  3. Already expired:
    1. Estate Tax, currently repealed, but jumping to 2001 law in 2011
    2. 71 other expired tax provisions, including the R&D tax credit.
  4. About to expire:
    1. Highway authorization
    2. flood insurance
    3. postponement of the 21% cut in Medicare physician reimbursement rates
  5. Defense supplemental to fund the Iraq and Afghanistan wars
  6. budget resolution
  7. Confirm non-controversial judges and other presidential appointees on "hold" for reasons having nothing to do with their qualifications.
  8. Financial reforms

The New Standard of Bipartisanship

It's funny how Republicans get credit for bipartisanship because 5 senators out of 41 voted with the Democrats on a tiny 15 billion dollar bill.

Talk about lowered expectations.

In any case, the solution is not to expect magic fairies to force the Republicans to be nice. It's to be realistic and abolish the filibuster so that the party in power can at least do something, try things, so problems can be solved, and we don't fall behind countries that can innovate and advance.

For more on this, please see:

Recent comments


Order from Amazon


Creative Commons LicenseThe content of is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 United States License. Need permissions beyond the scope of this license? Please submit a request here.