Lower FY09 Deficit, But Higher Deficits FY10 And Beyond
Sometime soon, probably on August 18th, the President's Office of Management and Budget will issue its Mid-Session Review of the Budget. No one has the numbers yet, but a consensus has emerged among Wall Street economists who follow the budget that the Fiscal 2009 deficit will come in about $200 billion lower than OMB's $1.841 trillion estimate of last May and that the Fiscal 2010 may come in slightly worse than OMB's $1.258 trillion. There are a lot of cross currents here. OMB's estimates will reflect the economy as it looked through June, and that was considerably worse than they assumed last spring. Therefore, weaker revenues and rising outlays for unemployment insurance, Medicaid, and interest expense on the public debt will add to the deficit, but reduced spending on TARP than was previously assumed and $70 billion of TARP repayments have reduced the deficit by an even larger amount. The Fiscal 2010 estimate is likely to rise because of higher than forecast unemployment will produce weaker revenues and higher outlays.
The Congressional Budget Office will report its Summer Update on August 25th. Its economic assumptions are likely to remain somewhat weaker than OMB's, and so it's deficit estimates should continue to be slightly worse as a result.
Last Wednesday, Treasury said Congress would have to raise the $12.104 trillion debt limit in the fourth quarter.
Last Monday, Treasury announced it will borrow $406 billion of marketable debt during the third quarter, $109 b. less than it estimated in April, and that it expects to borrow $486 billion in the fourth quarter. Treasury also announced, partly at the behest of China, that it will expand its offerings of Treasury Inflation-Indexed Securities (TIPS) and will consider replacing the 20-year TIPS with 30-year TIPS. It will announce any changes on November 4th. Last weeks talks with China reportedly featured reassurances by President Obama and Treasury Secretary Geithner that we would address out worsening deficit outlook without resorting to inflating our way out of it. If, at any point in the future, China begins to purchase less U.S. debt, out interest rates would be forced up as a consequence, endangering our fragile recovery.
Deficit fears
When China passes the U.S. as the world's dominant economy, you can blame the economists, who parrot the popular wisdom that federal debts are unsustainable and cause recessions, inflations, high taxes and harmful high interest rates. Surprisingly, no evidence supports these intuitive beliefs.
Contrary to popular wisdom:
--Fact: The U.S. government has the unlimited ability to print money, thus the unlimited ability to "sustain" any size debt. We do not need other nations to buy our debt.
--Fact: There is no relationship between deficits and inflation. Data indicates inflation is more closely related to energy costs, specifically oil, than to any other factor.
--Fact: In only 15 years, from 1979 through 1994, taxes were cut and the federal debt grew an astounding 500%. This massive, unprecidented money printing did not cause inflation or high taxes. Instead, we entered a long period of economic growth, low taxes and moderate interest rates. Repeating that 500% debt growth would yield a $72 trillion debt in 2024 and an average deficit of $4 trillion -- and the same economic growth, the same low taxes and the same moderate interest rates.
--Fact: All six depressions in U.S. history immediately followed years of federal surpluses. Every recovery coincided with increases in debt growth.
--Fact: All nine recessions in the past 50 years immediately followed reductions in federal debt growth. Every recovery coincided with increases in debt growth, such as we are seeing, today.
--Fact: There is no historical relationship between high interest rates and slow economic growth. Similarly, low interest rates have not stimulated growth.
--Fact: There is no historical relationship between deficits and tax rates. Without tax increases, there is no mechanism for our grandchildren to pay for deficits.
For data supporting the above facts, please Email me.
The factually unsupported fear of federal deficits in the U.S., when compared with the lack of such fear in China, is why we will fail and they will succeed.
Rodger Malcolm Mitchell
rmmadvertising@yahoo.com
http://www.rodgermitchell.com